Mississippi
Reconstruction Vignette
My Dear Wife: Yours is just received. I am glad to hear from you again. I can not send you any money now, because it is too unsafe, unless I can see some one going there. You had better try and make your arrangements to come out here to me. I think I can do well here. My master has good land. He has agreed to let us go and work it. He provides all the stock, farming utensils and land, and gives us half we can make. I am not able to go there now. so come out and bring all your children, and tell Neverson and William to Come. We can all do better here than we can there. Give my love to cousin Randall Quarles, and tell him his brother Wash is still with Master. We have plenty to eat here, good Clothes, and have found work generally. Remember me to father, my brothers, and all my friends. Write me again soon. Your affectionate husband, Moses Scott. |
On Dec. 17, 1865, a formerly enslaved man working on a plantation in Mississippi wrote this letter to his wife in Virginia. According to Freedmen’s Bureau records, Moses Scott and his wife Lily Ann had been separated and were trying to settle together in a place with means to provide for their family. No Bureau records indicate whether or not the couple reunited.
Mississippi
Standards Overview
Coverage of Reconstruction: Partial
ZEP Standards Rubric Score: 2 out of 10
The coverage of Reconstruction in Mississippi’s standards is partial, and their content is subpar. The Mississippi Department of Education adopted the current social studies standards in 2018. Reconstruction is covered in grade 4, middle school, and very briefly in high school.
Grade 4
Reconstruction is covered only briefly in grade 4, and with a decidedly negative slant. Students are asked to “trace the negative impact of the Civil War and Reconstruction on Mississippi.” These standards make mention of sharecropping and Jim Crow disenfranchisement, but do not pose any positive impacts of this period.
Middle School
The final unit of Mississippi’s middle school U.S. history course (taught in either grade 7 or 8) requires students to “Analyze the Reconstruction efforts in post-Civil War America.” Students should learn about various Reconstruction plans, the role of the Reconstruction Amendments in “expanding liberty,” and “the Southern resistance to Reconstruction reforms, including: Black Codes, Jim Crow Laws, Ku Klux Klan, etc.”
High School
The high school U.S. history course goes from Reconstruction to the present but, in fact, does not cover Reconstruction. Instead, it focuses on industrialization and westward expansion.
Several half-credit courses (Mississippi Studies, Problems in American Democracy, and African American Studies) cover Reconstruction in far more depth than the standard U.S. history courses. These courses mention the legacies of Reconstruction, the role of northern politics in the defeat of Reconstruction, and Black people's day-to-day experiences.
Educator Experiences
Theron Wilkerson, a social studies teacher in Jackson, emphasized in response to our survey that “the Reconstruction period is only a minor, if not completely ignored subject” in the high school U.S. history course and the standardized state exam. He added, “The U.S. Reconstruction period is central to understanding United States and global histories of chattel slavery and post-emancipation as well as the will to silence that history today.” Wilkerson teaches a course in African American Studies, which “offers more leeway to not only teach Reconstruction more thoroughly, but opportunities to explore the continuities and changes as sparked by Reconstruction in later periods across multiple disciplines.”
Other respondents to our survey expressed concern with the ongoing conservative effort to ban the teaching of “critical race theory” in classrooms. One educator noted that drawing connections to “Black History Month and celebrations of Juneteenth and national celebrations of period history” allowed them to introduce discussions of Reconstruction into their lessons.
In an interview for the Hechinger Report, Pascagoula teacher Cristina Tosto explained that she makes sure her students know that despite their state’s history of Jim Crow oppression, Mississippi elected the first African American to ever serve a full term in the U.S. Senate, Blanche K. Bruce, during Reconstruction. She added, “Often the history can be depressing, but there was a lot of progress made [during Reconstruction] and that’s what I teach my students. I want them to know that African-American history included progress, triumph and victory, as well as struggle.”
Columbus teacher Chuck Yarborough was interviewed for The Atlantic about why and how he teaches about Reconstruction. “You can’t understand American history without understanding the steps forward, racially and socioeconomically, that Reconstruction presented initially, and then the steps backward that were taken with the violent reestablishment of white supremacy. You can’t understand the present without seeing the connections between this history and the socioeconomic and racial imbalances it created. But Reconstruction is not on the state test. Therefore, the schools that are teaching the state tests are not teaching Reconstruction at all, and in today’s society, that’s particularly problematic. . . [When students arrive in my class], the vast majority of them have not been taught Reconstruction. So . . . I start with the end of the Civil War — 1865 — and then I teach Reconstruction for the first several weeks of the class.”
Assessment
Mississippi’s Reconstruction standards are inadequate. Notably lacking from the standards is any mention of the Freedmen's Bureau, Black political mobilization, the expansion of civil and political rights, or the role of white supremacist terrorism in defeating Reconstruction. It is especially troubling that students’ initial engagement and interpretation of Reconstruction in elementary school is focused on solely the "negative" aspects of the period, ignoring far-reaching gains made through organizing, educating, and legislating to expand political and social freedoms. While there is a more holistic presentation of Reconstruction in middle school, that initial framing could be difficult to overcome.
Particularly troubling is the description of white supremacist terrorism and racial disenfranchisement presented in the middle school standard as “Southern resistance to Reconstruction.” This framing conflates “Southern” with white, and erases positive accomplishments of Black Mississippians.
Coverage of Reconstruction in the standards for the optional Mississippi Studies, Problems in American Democracy, and African American Studies courses is far stronger than in the required history courses. Transferring elements of the standards from these courses into the core elementary and middle school history courses would go a long way toward improving Mississippi’s coverage of Reconstruction in the classroom.
Teaching Reconstruction effectively requires centering Black people’s struggles to redefine freedom and equality and gain control of their own land and labor during and after the Civil War. Any discussion of Reconstruction must also grapple with the role of white supremacist terrorism in the defeat of Reconstruction and the negative and positive legacies of the era that persist to this day.
In 2022, Republican lawmakers introduced HB437, a bill designed to prohibit schools from teaching “divisive concepts” or participating in “race or sex scapegoating.” They also introduced ten other bills that target teaching about racism or sexism in the classroom. SB2098, in particular, would require students to learn a “factually accurate history of the United States” that “shall not include the teaching of what is colloquially known as ‘critical race theory.’” Gov. Tate Reeves signed into law SB2113, which bans schools from making a “distinction or classification of students based on account of race.” Another bill died in committee in 2023. A 2024 bill that would have established “prohibited concepts” in schools and a reporting and investigation system also died in committee.
Several respondents to our survey expressed concern about the possible chilling effects on classroom education that such bills can have around the country, particularly on discussions of the history and legacies of Reconstruction.
Moments in Reconstruction history
This short list of events in Mississippi’s Reconstruction history is from the Zinn Education Project This Day in History collection. We welcome your suggestions for more.
Jan. 1868 Mississippi Constitutional Convention
The Mississippi Constitution was one of the first pieces of legislation that provided a uniform system of free public education for children regardless of race.
Jan. 1870 Hiram Rhodes Revels Elected to U.S. Senate During Reconstruction
Hiram Rhodes Revels was the first African American to be elected to serve in the U.S. Senate.
Jan. 1874 Adelbert Ames Becomes Governor of Mississippi
Adelbert Ames become the elected governor of Mississippi during the Reconstruction era.
Whites attacked and killed many Black citizens who had organized for a Black sheriff to remain in office during the Vicksburg Massacre.
Sept. 1875 Clinton, Mississippi Massacre
Nearly 50 African-Americans were killed by white mobs during the Clinton Riot.
March 1886 Carroll County Courthouse Massacre
The Carroll County Courthouse Massacre left 23 Black people dead when an armed white mob attacked an ongoing trial.
July 1890 F. M. B. “Marsh” Cook Killed
F. M. B. “Marsh” Cook, a white man, was killed for standing up against the white supremacist 1890 Mississippi Constitutional Convention.
Nov. 1890 Mississippi Constitution
Mississippi adopted a state constitution with poll tax and literacy tests to roll back the gains of the Reconstruction era.